Articles - Violence

OAK LEAVES FAMILY SERVICE COLUMN - OCTOBER, 1998

The shooting at the Capitol Building last summer got me wondering about what we’re doing as a society to help prevent future such tragedies. Just how common is such violent acts by the mentally ill?

The Capitol Building shooting that resulted in the death of two officers has directed new attention to the issues of the mentally ill. The individual responsible for the shooting was a person diagnosed with a serious and persistent mental illness -- schizophrenia. He had skipped his medication and had been without treatment for some time. Schizophrenia is a chronic and disabling brain disorder that can cause delusions and hallucinations and keeps individuals from thinking clearly and managing their emotions and behavior. When properly treated with medication, psychotherapy and case management, up to 90 percent of individuals with schizophrenia improve. Tragically, in the case last summer, a lack of ongoing treatment resulted in an individual committing a terrible offense which resulted in a senseless loss of life.

October is Mental Health Awareness Month. For more information on the realities of mental illness check out these resources:
  • National Alliance for the Mentally Ill, Metro Suburban Chapter (708) 524-2582
  • Mental Health Association of Illinois (312) 368-9070
  • Torrey, M.D. and Fuller (1988). Surviving Schizophrenia: A Family Manual. New York: Harper & Row
In reality, people suffering from mental illness, including schizophrenia, are no more violent than some one suffering from cancer, diabetes, heart disease or any other serious disease. In fact, many psychiatric patients are so terrified of the world that they withdraw completely, preferring isolation rather than any level of interaction -- violent or other -- with their fellow human beings.

According to the American Psychiatric Association, no one can predict when a person may become violent because everyone has a stress threshold that is unique. Where one may react in violent anger under stress, others continue unfazed. In short, a person=s personality, not mental or physical health, has more influence on their potential for violence.

Research supports this fact. People suffering from mental illness are no more likely to be arrested because of crimes than the general population. According to studies at Northwestern University Medical School, fewer than one out of 20 police contacts with citizens were with victims of mental illness. Of those contacts who were found to be mentally ill, half of them were simply approached because the police assumed they required assistance, not because they were suspected of any crime or wrongdoing.

“Most people with mental illness are not violent, and, in fact, are frequently the victims, not the perpetrators of violence in our society,” says Nancy Fidler, M.A., LCPC, Coordinator of Family Service’s Transitional Learning Center, a daily rehabilitation program for adults who have been recently hospitalized for mental illness. “These individuals need our community’s wholehearted support including ongoing medical treatment, housing, rehabilitation and other support systems. With this kind of network they can effectively manage their illness.”

The Illinois chapter of the National Association for the Mentally Ill (NAMI) agrees: ”The tragedy of the Russell Weston story and thousands like him is that the care they really need is not always available . . . The inability to provide needed treatment increases the potential for violent acts. The bottom line is that senseless tragedies can be prevented.” NAMI Illinois cites the need for treatment centers that provide 24-hour-a-day outreach and crisis support for those who find it difficult to maintain treatment regimens. The advocacy group also believes that court ordered outpatient treatment is necessary for those who do not properly respond to treatment or otherwise resist recommended services.

One in five Americans will suffer from mental illness during some time in their lives. With early diagnosis, proper treatment, and community support and understanding, our mentally ill family members, neighbors and friends can live full and productive lives within the communities they call home.



Located at 120 S. Marion, Oak Park, Family Service & Mental Health Center of Oak Park & River Forest is a not-for-profit social service and mental health agency that provides counseling, psychiatric and prevention/education programs to men, women, youth and families. To learn more about our programs or to make an appointment, contact us at (708) 383-7500.

Family Service & Mental Health Center of Oak Park and River Forest
120 South Marion Street, Oak Park, Illinois 60302
Tel: (708) 383-7500 Fax: (708) 383-7780